Let us show you how we CARE

As part of our CUSTOMER ACCOUNT REVIEW EXPERIENCE, we’ll perform a complete account analysis of all your policies every year at renewal, without any hassle to you. Because we’re not tied to a single insurance company, we can shop around for you to find the best insurance plan for your needs.


Step 1 Call or click to get started.

Call 800-627-4441 or fill out a quick form and we’ll get started on shopping for your best insurance coverage.

Step 2 We shop so you don't have to.

Because we’re not tied to any single insurance company, we’ll get you quotes from up to 12 insurance companies - all rated “A” or better - within 24 hours.

Step 3 We'll send you annual coverage reviews.

Every year, we’ll do a complete account analysis of all your policies, evaluating coverage, limits, and premiums, and we’ll shop around to find you a better plan - without any hassle on your part.

Call today to get started:
800-627-4441 or 706-629-4441

Auto

Solid coverage at competitive pricing offers your family the best protection on the road.

Business

Protect your business from unknown exposures, loss and liabilities.

Home

Our agents are ready to help you keep your home secure, both inside and out.

Health

Maximize saving with a group health plan for businesses of all sizes.

life.jpg

Life

Stabilize and plan for your family’s future through life insurance.

Financial Services

Our retirement planning and wealth management team is eager to help you achieve your financial goals.

Get a QuoteGet an Instant Quote today for coverage for your Home or Car

Get a Quote

Get an Instant Quote today for coverage for your Home or Car

Payments & ClaimsMake a payment or report a claim.

Payments & Claims

Make a payment or report a claim.

Risk ManagementImplement proactive risk management approaches with our web-based tools

Risk Management

Implement proactive risk management approaches with our web-based tools

Questions about a claim? Contact our Claims Specialist at 800-627-4441 or 706-629-4441.

Insurance Since 1920

Starr-Mathews Agency, Inc. is a locally owned independent insurance agency serving clients in Georgia and Tennessee. Our goal is to find the best insurance products and financial solutions for our customers’ needs. We are committed to providing our clients in Northwest Georgia and Southeast Tennessee expertise, value and service that is second to none.


Protection for Your Home and Business

  • Personal insurance: We will work with you to assess your specific needs and find the policies that are best suited to your lifestyle, your budget and the risks you face. Look no further than Starr-Mathews Agency for car insurancehomeowners or renters insurance, and personal umbrella insurance. We also offer coverage for your recreational vehicles, boats, and even classic cars. 

  • Commercial insurance: Every business is different, and Starr-Mathews Agency will work with you to determine the precise risks your business faces and design the most appropriate business insurance package. With access to numerous insurance companies we can help you secure the best coverage for every facet of your business, from commercial auto insurance to business owners policies, general liability and more. We commit to providing our business clients with unmatched experience, knowledge, and access to products that will help you protect your assets and meet your business goals. 

  • Life insurance and financial services: Financial planning for the future gives you peace of mind today. Life and disability insurance are two vital components of a sound financial plan. We offer a variety of life and disability insurance solutions, as well as strategies for designing, implementing and monitoring your entire retirement plan. 

  • Health insurance and employee benefits: We provide health insurance plans for individuals as well as group health, dental and vision plans for small and large businesses. Our comprehensive employee benefits program also includes design, implementation and continued support for 401K plans for larger employers.

Value of Choosing an Independent Agency

As an independent agency we do not limit you to one choice for your insurance needs. We represent not one, but over thirty insurance companies and specialty markets, allowing us to find a solution for every type of risk you face in both your business and personal life. We offer personalized service and our agents are here to help in the event of a loss. Our highly trained claims department will help you navigate the claims process and will be your advocate in the event of a loss. As a local business we have a real commitment to the communities in which we live and serve. We are here with you, working for you. We review your coverages annually to make sure you have the right coverage at the right price. We always have other markets to consider in the event your current carrier is no longer a good fit for you due to price or coverage.

Knowledge is Important

Insurance coverage can be hard to understand. What coverages do I really need? Will minimum limits on an auto policy be enough coverage in the event of an accident? What is Uninsured Motorist coverage? Am I missing out on a discount that I am eligible for? Our staff of over forty experienced agents place a high value on educating our customers. We spend time with every client analyzing insurance needs and reviewing coverage to make sure they are making the best decisions for their individual or business insurance needs.

Contact us for Personal and Business Solutions in Georgia and Tennessee

We proudly service clients from our headquarters in Calhoun, Georgia, as well as our offices in Cartersville, Dalton, Ringgold, Rome, GA and Chattanooga, TN. Contact us today to receive a quote or to begin discussing your insurance and financial services needs.

Latest News

The Simple Tactic You May Be Overlooking to Reduce Your Work Comp Experience Mod

Wed, March 13, 2024

As a business owner or manager, you’re surely providing safety meetings and training for your workers to keep your workplace injuries at a minimum. You probably have upped your PPE game with the latest in hard hats (or helmets), gloves, and eye protection. You’re perhaps even considering in- vehicle monitoring for your company vehicles to avoid accidents. These are all great tactics and can result in better work comp experience, but do you have clear and consistent procedure for ...Read More

Unlock Peace of Mind: The Comprehensive Guide to the Best Insurance Coverage for Your Jewelry

Wed, February 14, 2024

Valentine's Day is just around the corner, and with it comes the sparkle of love in the form of exquisite jewelry. Whether it's an engagement ring, a dazzling necklace, or a pair of elegant earrings, these precious pieces hold not only monetary value but also sentimental worth. As you bask in the joy of receiving or gifting high-value jewelry, it's crucial to consider the need for the best insurance coverage. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the world of Inland Marine ...Read More

Water Woes Can Be Cut Off, By an Automatic Shutoff

Wed, January 10, 2024

Water damage can wreak havoc on your home, causing significant financial and emotional distress. Whether it's a burst pipe, a malfunctioning appliance, or a natural disaster, water damage is a pervasive threat that homeowners need to address proactively. In recent years, technological advancements have introduced innovative solutions to mitigate this risk. One such breakthrough is the automatic water shutoff device. In this blog post, we'll explore the importance of these devices in ...Read More

Navigating the Winter Wonderland: Your Guide to Safe Driving this Season

Wed, December 13, 2023

In Georgia and Tennessee, we may not see a lot of snow this winter season, but wherever you travel please refer to this guide to keep you safe on the roadways. Here’s the essential tips and tricks to ensure your winter driving experience is not only safe but stress-free.1)      Prepare Your Vehicle:a.       Winter Tires: Not always necessary in Tennessee and Georgia, however, make sure your current tires still have a lot of life ...Read More